Injury Report, August 6

4 ranked players had an injury reported in the last day.

Team medical staffs and beat reporters moved 4 ranked players in the last day. This is the ranked-only list, an injury to someone the board does not carry is not a fantasy decision, so those are left out, ordered by the value actually at risk rather than by when it was reported.

Who moved

What the reports say

Willson Contreras: Contreras went 0-for-5 in Sunday's 8-4 win over the Dodgers.

Kyle Harrison: Harrison was removed from Wednesday's game against Pittsburgh with an apparent injury, Adam McCalvy of MLB.com reports.

Derek Hill: Hill went 1-for-3 with a grand slam in Monday's 6-3 win over Washington.

Andrew Painter: Painter will start Wednesday's game against the Nationals in Philadelphia.

The calls

Hold, day-to-day, not an IL move: Willson Contreras

Bench, day-to-day and replaceable: Kyle Harrison, Derek Hill, Andrew Painter

What this means

Contreras is the entire list. A value of 289 puts him just under the top five percent of ranked players, and he is day to day, which is the worst combination on a roster because it asks you to make a decision every morning without ever giving you the information to make it. The verdict is Hold, and that is right, but Hold is doing more work than it looks like. It means you eat the zeros rather than move him, and in a weekly-lineup format it means you may eat a week of them.

The mechanism here is not complicated and it is not really about Contreras. Day-to-day is a label that covers everything from a player who sits one game to a player who is on the injured list in four days, and nothing in today's data separates those two. What makes him a Hold at 289 is the replacement math, not optimism about the injury. The gap between him and the last man rostered, who sits around 134, is enormous. Even a version of Contreras who misses half the week and comes back at less than full strength out-earns the free agent you would replace him with. You are not holding because he is fine. You are holding because the alternative is bad.

The case against, and it is a real one, is that replacement-adjusted value is a full-season measure and your week is not a full season. If you are in a head-to-head matchup you expect to lose by a category or two, a healthy body who plays six games beats a 289 who plays one. That argument wins in a bench-slot-poor roster with a tight matchup, and it loses everywhere else. The falsifier is simple and you will have it inside forty-eight hours: if he is out of the lineup two straight days without a clear day-off explanation, treat the DTD as a stint on the shelf in waiting and stash accordingly. If he starts tomorrow, the question never existed.

Below him the list is noise, and the number tells you why. Harrison at 91 is the closest thing to a debate, and it is not close. He carries SP and RP eligibility, which is genuinely useful in formats that squeeze relief innings, but 91 sits well under the 134 line that marks the last roster spot in a standard twelve-team league. A player who is not clearly rosterable when healthy does not become a decision when he is hurt. Bench is correct, and in most leagues so is drop. Hill at 56 is the same case with less to argue about.

Painter is the one people will want to talk about, and the number is 26. That is not a statement about talent and I would not read it as one. Replacement-adjusted value with a day-to-day tag attached is a rest-of-season expectation, and 26 says the engine expects very little playing time to be delivered from here. If you are in a keeper or dynasty league, none of this touches you, because that value is not trying to price 2027. In a redraft league the action is: hold him in a minors slot if you have one, cut him if you do not, and do not use an active bench spot on 26.

So the shape of today's list is one real decision and three filings. Contreras is the only name where being wrong costs you anything, and the cost of being wrong on him runs in both directions: hold him through a stint on the shelf and you burn a week, cut him and you hand someone a top-five-percent bat. Hold, and check the lineup card tomorrow.

How to read this

The verdicts are the engine's, not a hot take, and the cutoffs come from the board rather than from taste: value 295 is the top 5% of ranked players, and value 134 is roughly the 300th-ranked player, the last man rostered in a 12-team league. Above 295 nobody drops anyone; below 134 the player is a free agent in most formats whether he is hurt or not.

Status is the IL designation itself, which is the only honest signal of length available: the feed carries no return dates and no estimated timelines at all, both fields are empty on every record, so anyone quoting a return date is guessing. A 60-day placement is the club saying months; a 10-day is a fortnight.

Value is the replacement-adjusted number the boards sort on, so it answers the only question that matters here: how much is actually at stake. A high-value name on a short absence is usually a hold; a mid-value name on a long one is where roster spots get decided.

All articles · Redraft rankings · Dynasty rankings