Where We Disagree, September 23

0 players we rank far above the consensus, 44 we rank far below.

Everyone publishes the consensus. The only thing worth saying against it is where our own board departs from it, and by how much. These are the 44 players the engine and the expert consensus disagree about most sharply today, with injured players removed from both sides.

We are lower

The consensus treats these as startable, inside the top 150, and the engine does not have them in its top 400. None of them are hurt; that filter is applied before this list is built, because "the engine discounts a pitcher who is not pitching" is not a disagreement worth publishing.

PlayerPosConsensusOur rankSpreadProj pts
Roman AnthonyOF/DH41492389
Luis Robert Jr.OF486612106
Jake BennettSP5960618114
Kodai SengaSP+RP646191086
Lars NootbaarOF695054152
Max ClarkOF724082117
Dylan CrewsOF754127184
Josh LoweOF8366714108
Luis CastilloSP+RP9155820135
Ryan WaldschmidtOF916033092
Dylan BeaversOF1004308140
Carlos CortesOF10142128189

_Showing 12 of 44._

How to read this

Consensus rank and its spread come from FantasyPros. Spread is the standard deviation across the experts who ranked him: a small number means they agree with each other, which makes a gap against our board more interesting, not less. Players ranked by only one source carry no real consensus and are excluded entirely.

Injured players are removed from both directions. Without that filter, more than a third of the "we are lower" list is simply players on the IL, and the top of it is injured aces the consensus still ranks highly as keepers, a comparison that says nothing about either opinion. 16 players were dropped for that reason today.

This is a disagreement report, not a waiver-availability report. We cannot see your league, and no roster-percentage feed backs this site, so consensus rank is used as the proxy for whether a player is gettable.

All articles · Redraft rankings · Dynasty rankings

Skip to main content

Redraft Rest of Season

Sorted by -
Loading history…
Official MiLB Prospect Rankings

Official MiLB Prospect Rankings

Loading…
Loading rankings…
Overview

Operations Dashboard

Portfolio and league analytics.
Workspace ready
Use Sync to import a roster.

2026 FYPD Class

Players entering the MiLB system for the first time: the 2026 MLB Draft class and first-time international signees. Ranked by dynasty value: a measured expectation from draft slot or debut production, adjusted by the age curve. For established prospects, see the Prospect board.

Prospect Player Rankings

Top-100 + all 30 org Top-30 lists · ranked by projected Prospect Value · AAA Statcast tools →
Loading prospect rankings…
Loading study…

Methodology

Every signal, formula, and data source the model uses for player evaluation - organized by product.

Loading methodology…

Risers & Fallers - last 30 days