Payton Tolle

Payton Tolle is a Boston Red Sox SP+RP projected for 378 fantasy points on 156.8 IP, 182 K, 3 ERA, 1.116 WHIP by the managr projection engine. Monte-Carlo outcome odds put an elite season at 0% and a bust at 14%.

Team
Boston Red Sox
Position
SP+RP
Projected fantasy points
378
Projected innings
156.8
Projected strikeouts
182
Projected ERA
3
Projected WHIP
1.116
Projected wins
9.7
Projected hits allowed
131
Projected earned runs
53
Projected walks allowed
43
Floor (10th percentile)
360
Median outcome
378
Upside (90th percentile)
605
Elite-season odds
0%
Bust odds
14%

Projection snapshot: 2026-09-28. Rebuilt daily.

Player report

Payton Tolle's 2026 projection is built on 157 innings as a full-time starter.

Tolle's one season with meaningful innings came in 2026 at age 23: 149 innings with 171 strikeouts. A single season is a thin base for a projection.

In 2026, Tolle's 3.03 ERA sat close to a 2.70 expected ERA, so the runs allowed matched the quality of contact.

Tracking data from 2026: Tolle struck out 28.4% of batters and walked 6.6%, a strikeout-minus-walk rate of 21.8 points, and hitters missed on 27.9% of their swings. Contact against Tolle averaged 87.6 mph off the bat, with a 6.0% barrel rate.

Recent pitch tracking flags Tolle's arsenal as trending up. Over the last 374 pitches, the whiff rate sits 2 points below and the called-strike-plus-whiff rate sits 3 points above Tolle's own baseline. The engine applies a +4% adjustment to the rest-of-season projection for a move this size; the full-season projection is untouched.

Tolle's projected range runs from a 360-point floor to a 605-point upside, around a 378-point median: a spread of 245 points, or 65% of the median.

By statistical profile, the closest comparisons to Tolle on the board are Joe Ryan, Nathan Eovaldi and Hunter Brown.

At 23, Tolle is early in the typical pitcher development arc, and the multi-year valuation adds weight for expected growth.

This report is generated from the managr engine's 2026-09-28 snapshot and rebuilt daily.

Redraft rankings · Dynasty rankings · Injury report

Skip to main content

Redraft Rest of Season

Sorted by -
Loading history…
Official MiLB Prospect Rankings

Official MiLB Prospect Rankings

Loading…
Loading rankings…
Overview

Operations Dashboard

Portfolio and league analytics.
Workspace ready
Use Sync to import a roster.

2026 FYPD Class

Players entering the MiLB system for the first time: the 2026 MLB Draft class and first-time international signees. Ranked by dynasty value: a measured expectation from draft slot or debut production, adjusted by the age curve. For established prospects, see the Prospect board.

Prospect Player Rankings

Top-100 + all 30 org Top-30 lists · ranked by projected Prospect Value · AAA Statcast tools →
Loading prospect rankings…
Loading study…

Methodology

Every signal, formula, and data source the model uses for player evaluation - organized by product.

Loading methodology…

Risers & Fallers - last 30 days